2009 De-Terminator Plot Results

Thanks to several third-party cooperators Case IH was able to plant 9 De-Terminator plots in 6 different states in the spring of 2009.  20 different seeds sizes were tested at 5 different planting speeds. Over 397 side-by-side comparisons were conducted with 27,790 plant measurements taken. 

Plots were planted with The DeTerminator planter which was specially designed and built for this research.  The planter was setup in the following configuration:

  • Row 1 – Kinze EdgeVac seed meter and row unit
  • Row 2 – Case IH Advanced Seed Meter and Early Riser row unit
  • Row 3 – Standard Kinze finger meter and row unit
  • Row 4 – AGCO White seed meter and row unit
  • Row 5 - Case IH Advanced Seed Meter and Early Riser row unit
  • Row 6 – John Deere vacuum seed meter and row unit

Plant stand measurements were collected in June when plants were in the 4-8 leaf stage.  Plant populations, in-row plant spacing and late emerging plants were recorded.  Results from the various comparisons are expressed as Net Effective Stand Percentage.

 

Two Important Definitions

  1. Net Effective Stand = total plant population minus (-) late emerging plants minus (-) poorly spaced plants
  2. Net Effective Stand Percentage = net effective stand divided by (/) total plant population

Late emerging plants are easily identified because they have fewer leaves than plants that emerged uniformly. Poorly spaced plants have space between each other that is less distance or more distance than the target plant spacing. As important as proper plant spacing is, uniform emergence is much more critical to high yields. See the examples below that show lack of emergence uniformity and notice the impact on ear size.

Late Emerger

This late emerging plant is stunted and behind it's neighboring plants in June

1leaf

Ears from plants 1 leaf behind in June and subsequent ears from both sides

2leaf

Ears from plants 2 leaves behind in June and subsequent ears from both sides

2leaf

Ears from crowded plants and subsequent ears from both sides

poorstand

A typical "poor" quality plant stand including late emerging plants and crowding

goodstand

A typical "good" quality plant stand

Field Shot